Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019

Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review

Best Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews.

Unlike real fireplaces, fireplace inserts don’t have a real flame making them safer and more affordable.

Depending on the room size, energy efficient inserts cost only 2¢ per hour.

Here are my picks for best fireplace insert online.

Best Electric Fireplace Insert 

 Top #1 Pick: Dimplex Electric Fireplace Deluxe

Dimplex Electric Fireplace Deluxe

Check Price Button

Buyers have been liking how the Dimplex Electric Fireplace Deluxe models are very easy to install.

Personally, I love how the fireplace includes a fan – having a fan helps distribute the heat evenly throughout the room. Since it is not a real fireplace, a fan is almost necessary in extracting the heat. Most fireplace inserts lack this noticeable feature.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert w/ Quiet Operation ⭐⭐

Dimplex inserts have a very quiet operation; they even make a subtle flame sound (without the flame of course).

With 1375W of energy capable of heating areas of 400 sq. ft.

Includes 3 different heating modes: half heat, full heat, or flame only

Using the remote control you can change the settings without having to leave the couch.


  • Size: 23.2″ x 19.8″ x 10.8″
  • Weight: 30 pounds
  • Heating power: 1375W
  • Room size: 400 square feet
  • 3 modes of heating:
    • Full heat ; Half heat ; Flame only
  • Best fireplace insert for low noise
  • Comes w/ built-in fan
  • Remote control included

Potential Flaws

  • Not the best design for some

Amazon Price >>

#2.) PuraFlame Alice 40″ Electric Fireplace

PuraFlame Alice 40″ Electric Fireplace

Check Price Button

I personally like this one because the flame looks very realistic.

The one thing that stands out is it’s size — even though it’s 40″ you’ll notice that it’s wider than most electric fireplaces. (not better or nor worse, just a style preference)

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Wider Walls ⭐⭐

Right away you’ll notice the PuraFlame “Alice” Fireplace has ultra-high intensity LED lights giving it a brighter, sharper flame. You can even control the flame settings to match your ambiance:

full-yellow, yellow w/ blue, or full-blue

Comes w/ full-functional remote control:

– Heat or no heat
– 2 heat settings (750W or 1500W)
– Timer: 30 mins to 9 hours

In terms of heating, this electric fireplace alone can heat up to 400 sq. ft. (moderate size living room)

Made of tempered glass, the PuraFlame Alice is easy installation and comes w/ a built-in thermostat.


  • Fireplaces sizes: 4
    • 40″ ; 50″ ; 60″ ; 68″
  • Weight: 62.6 pounds (40″ model)
  • Timer range: 30 mins – 9 hours
  • Room size: 400 sq. ft.
  • Remote control included
  • Realistic flame w/ color options
  • Built-in thermostat
  • Very easy to install

Potential Flaws

  • Not the most powerful for heating

Check Amazon Price >>

#3.) Classic Flame Electric Insert (36EB110-GRT)Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019 2

Check Price Button

ClassicFlame Fireplace insert has a natural look and lets you set the temp from 60°F90°F.

Operates at 4,400 BTU – powerful enough to heat rooms up to 400 square feet.

What makes it unique is the remote control — Unlike other remote control fireplaces, it’s multifunctional letting you turn on/off + set the exact temp you want.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert with Functional Remote ⭐⭐

ClassicFlame also comes with a built-in thermostat which can be wall mounted.

I liked how you can turn the flame on without the heater running – it adds a fantastic glow even during the warmer months.

Flame effects come w/ 5 brightness settings and includes a timer (30 mins to 9 hours)

** Also read our review of Top 8 Fireplace TV Stands


  • Size: 36″ x 7.6″ x 24″
  • Weight: 67.1 pounds
  • Room size: 400 square feet
  • Heating power: 4,400 BTU
  • Temp range: 60°F – 90°F
  • Timer: 30 mins – 9 hours
  • Best fireplace insert w/ multifunctional remote control
  • Fireplace insert sizes: 5
    • 23 inches ; 26 inches
    • 28 inches ; 33 inches (3D flame) – view here
    • 36 inches
  • Multi-functional remote control

Potential Flaws

  • Design may not look great in some homes

View Amazon Price >>

#4.) Classic Flame 33II310GRA Fireplace Insert

Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019 3

Check Price Button

I was impressed by how the The ClassicFlame Fireplace Insert can heat very large rooms – up rooms of 1,000 square feet. (others max out at 400 sq. ft.)

It comes with an electronic timer system. This allows you to set specific operating times that will switch off by itself after between 30 minutes and 9 hours.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Large Rooms ⭐⭐

Using the remote control you are able to turn on the flame without heating. Users have been liking this feature as it means they can create an ambiance during warmer weather, without having to heat up the room.

For the times where you do want to use the heat, you can make use of the infrared technology available. It works to keep the humidity in the air the same to avoid creating a dry effect in your room.

Also includes a built-in thermostat which can be adjusted to your liking. This gives you more control over the exact temperatures you want.


  • Size: 10.4″ x 34.1″ x 26.1″
  • Weight: 48 pounds
  • Timer range: 30 mins – 9 hours
  • Room size: 1,000 square feet
  • Heating power: 5,200 BTU
  • ** Remote control included
  • Very easy to install
  • Best electric fireplace insert for bigger living rooms
  • Safer Plug safety feature
    • Monitors the temp and will auto turn off if too high
  • Thermostat included

Potential Flaws

  • Flame is not as realistic as other inserts

Check Amazon Price >>

#5.) PuraFlame Electric Fireplace InsertPuraFlame Western Electric Fireplace Insert

Check Price Button

This PuraFlame Wester Electric Fireplace Insert includes awesome LED tech. I liked how it’s effective at saving energy so you can use it as much as you want without increasing the bills too much!

Alter the flame intensity between 3 different settings.

You’re also able to control how brightly you want it to shine. Users have been liking how you can have the fireplace lit up without creating any heat.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Easy Install ⭐⭐

Controlling the temperature is very easy as a result of the electronic temperature control. You can change the temperature anywhere from 6– 84° Fahrenheit. 

Also comes with a remote control allowing you to turn on or off.

We recommend using this fireplace insert to heat up spaces of up to 400 square feet.

Best of all – from reading reviews, the PuraFlame Fireplace Insert is very easy to install.


  • Size: 31.89″ x 8.78″ x 24.61″
  • Weight: 45.7 pounds   
  • Room size: 400 square feet
  • Temp range: 60°F – 84°F
  • Best fireplace insert for easy installation
  • ** Remote control included
  • Comes in 3 different sizes
    • 26″ insert ; 30″ insert ; 33″ insert
  • No flame or harmful emissions = very safe
  • 3 flame intensity settings

Potential Flaws

  • Limited heating options compared to others

Check Amazon Price >>

#6.) Valuxhome Houselux Review

Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019 4

Check Price Button

The Valuxhome Houselux electric fireplace insert has been created with a brick design. Users have been loving this design feature as it adds a much more realistic look.

Total of 3 lighting options — You can alter the brightness to suit your room at different times of the day.

You can also use a variety of heat settings. They include just the flame (with no heat), half heat, or full heat. Therefore, it’s awesome to use all-year round.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for All Year-Round Use ⭐⭐

To provide you with complete control over all these settings, it comes w/ a remote control – Turn on/off or set a timer function from 1 and 9 hours.

Operates on LED technology, which is very energy efficient.

Functions with just 120V and can effectively heat up rooms of 400 sq. ft.

Also comes w/ safety features — fireplace auto turns off if over heated. overheated.


  • Size: 30.5″ x 9.05″ x 24.9″
  • Weight: 42.3 pounds
  • Temp range: 71°F – 99°F
  • Timer: 1 – 9 hours
  • Power: 750/1500 Watts
  • Best fireplace insert for all year use
  • Safety controls
    • Over-heat kill switch
  • Remote control included
  • 3 lighting options 

Potential Flaws

  • Opening at the back may be an issue for some

View Amazon Price >>

#7.) R.W.FLAME Electric Fireplace Insert

Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019 5

Check Price Button

R.W. electric fireplace insert has a fantastic LED touch-screen panel — easily change between the various settings available.

You can choose between a total of 5 different flame modes in speed and color. I liked this feature as it provided you with complete control over how you want to heat your room. It also helps you achieve the best ambiance in the room.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Temperature Control ⭐⭐

There are 2 heat settings to choose from: 1500W and 750W

Setting 750W is best for saving energy and smaller rooms during warmer weather. Once it starts getting colder, you may need to switch to the 1500W to produce more heat.

The R.W.Flame Fireplace Insert also comes with a safety kill switch – it automatically turns fireplace off during instances where it becomes overheated too.


  • Size: 36″ x 27″ x 9″
  • Weight: 66.4 pounds
  • Room size: 400 square feet
  • Temp range: 71°F – 99°F
  • ** Remote control included
  • 5 operating modes
  • 2 heat settings – 750W and 1500W
  • Best fireplace insert for temp control
  • Safety kill switch

Potential Flaws

  • Heater fan can be a little noisy

View Amazon Price >>

#8.) Dimplex DFI2309 Review – Electric Fireplace Insert

Top 10 Best Electric Fireplace Insert Review 2019 6

Check Price Button

Dimplex electric fireplace insert operates with 1357W heating power – enough to heat rooms up to 400 square ft.

You can also toggle between three different heating modes: full heat, half heat, and flame only.

Paired with a built-in fan, heat is evenly distributed throughout the room.

 ⭐⭐ Best Electric Fireplace Insert for Heat Distribution ⭐⭐

Users have also appreciated how easily they’re able to install this fireplace. It fits easily into most outlets in regular households.

You can change between the various heat settings which allow you to enjoy the fireplace all-year round.


  • Size: 10.4″ x 5″ x 19.4″
  • Weight: 34 pounds
  • Heating power: 1375W
  • Room size: 400 square feet
  • No flame or harmful emissions = very safe
  • ** Remote control included
  • Best fireplace insert for even heat distribution
  • Built-in fan
  • Remote included

Potential Flaws

  • Flame is not super realistic

View Amazon Price >>

** I’ll be adding #9-10 best electric fireplace insert heaters later this year. Stay tuned!

Best Electric Fireplace Insert Reviews

Top 10 Best Heated Toilet Seat Bidets
Top 6 Outdoor Fire Pit Tables
Best Forced Air Heater Review
Top 10 Mini Split Heat Pumps + AC
Stefan’s Review of 10 Best Garage Heaters
Review of Top Ventless Heaters for Home

Stephen is a freelance writer from the UK specializing in health, fitness, and consumer reviews. When he’s not typing away at his laptop, he loves to hit the weights to stay fit.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *